Nice visual (must have been a faf to do! haha) and nice thought too. But there isn't really a benefit to it, no reason to buy the product and there isn't anything to differentiate from PG etc Has to be a pay off in reading the copy too, have you read Scamps tip today? Deffinatly something in it though. Push it further.
I hate sounding all Creative Director on you though, sorry!
I like it. I think the strapline needs looking at as its a little cold and would be nice if it was warmer and chatty, like the feeling is when you have a natter over a brew. If it was combined with a really nice 'neighbourly' kind of copy as the steam then I think it could be a good read.
yes, however this is just for the visual style of the poster the first few lines allow the idea to come through without having to read the whole thing,
I understand your point, but we don't intend for it to be read, the shape of the steam doesn't allow for easy reading anyway, we thought it was just a nice visual.
Each to their own, we'll see how it goes when we go for some crits.
it's just that if you follow the law of subtraction or as we were told 'KIFS' aka Keep It Fucking Simple and you don't require the audience to read it then it's surely something that has to be removed.
Therefore the idea may be null I can see what the strategy but surely there's a less predictable/old skool way
All the views on this page represent
me. Not any agency I may work for in the future. Just me. I hope not to offend anyone so thank you for coming, I hope you enjoy your stay and visit me again soon.
22, Insomniac and self confessed chocoholic. Watches way too much tv and thats probably why shes doing what she does... Gets what she wants most of the time and isnt afraid to fight for it. She thinks about things too much and verbalises most of it (unfortunately...)
Debbie
22, but doesn't know what she is...she's still trying to figure it out herself and when she does she will get back to you...
14 comments:
Nice visual (must have been a faf to do! haha) and nice thought too. But there isn't really a benefit to it, no reason to buy the product and there isn't anything to differentiate from PG etc Has to be a pay off in reading the copy too, have you read Scamps tip today? Deffinatly something in it though. Push it further.
I hate sounding all Creative Director on you though, sorry!
Lol actually it wasn't, illustrator has some nifty tricks!
Don't worry about it I asked for opinions,Yep I did see scamps post, I got bitch slapped for using cliche's (what a surprise).
Thanks.
I wouldn't say it was a huge cliche but just needs to be more benefit driven. Nothing there makes me want to buy Tetley.
Lol no I meant I got bitch slapped on scamps post for using a cliche!
I like it. I think the strapline needs looking at as its a little cold and would be nice if it was warmer and chatty, like the feeling is when you have a natter over a brew. If it was combined with a really nice 'neighbourly' kind of copy as the steam then I think it could be a good read.
agree with adam, strapline needs some work
check out freddie and hollies tetley idea thats very nice
way to obvious, got bored after the second line... sorry
you don't need to read it, its visual copy rather than informational copy.
erm copy is suppose to be read, isn't it?
yes, however this is just for the visual style of the poster the first few lines allow the idea to come through without having to read the whole thing,
I understand your point, but we don't intend for it to be read, the shape of the steam doesn't allow for easy reading anyway, we thought it was just a nice visual.
Each to their own, we'll see how it goes when we go for some crits.
it's just that if you follow the law of subtraction or as we were told 'KIFS' aka Keep It Fucking Simple and you don't require the audience to read it then it's surely something that has to be removed.
Therefore the idea may be null I can see what the strategy but surely there's a less predictable/old skool way
The line needs to be a bit less obvious. You're already showing me conversations in the visual, why tell that to me again in the line?
I'd like it better if the end line would be:
'have a seat, have a cuppa.'
that's a freebie for you girls.
you see anons aren't arseholes all the time.
have a break, have a kit kat
Post a Comment